Indoor trainer recommendations?

Does anyone have any recommendations for an good indoor trainer?

Views: 914

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by wigner on September 30, 2011 at 7:26am

$50 for booties

$50 for awesome lobster gloves

$10 for one of those cool hat/mask combos i think they're named after a greek desert blackula or something...

If I double check my math, that would come up to... about $83.76 to be able to ride in comfort outside all winter.
Your welcome.

Enjoy!

Permalink Reply by S on September 30, 2011 at 9:11am

That doesn't work for the a lot of the things you'd want to use a trainer for.  For example, I'd be very wary of doing hard sprinting or long intervals outside on the LFP or streets during winter but doing that is feasible on a trainer.  You can even do out of the saddle sprinting on some of the trainers out there.  Trying to do that outdoors during winter is just asking to crash when you hit a slippery patch.

There's a difference between being able to ride in comfort outdoors and doing athletic training on a bike outdoors.

wigner said:

$50 for booties

$50 for awesome lobster gloves

$10 for one of those cool hat/mask combos i think they're named after a greek desert blackula or something...

If I double check my math, that would come up to... about $83.76 to be able to ride in comfort outside all winter.
Your welcome.

Enjoy!

Permalink Reply by John S. on September 30, 2011 at 9:20am

A fluid based trainer is usually your best bet with the exception of 1up USA trainers.  Roadbike Review has a section for trainers.  As you can see it's sorted by rating.  I ignore anything with less than 10 people reviewing it.  The 1up USA trainer has over 100 reviews with one of the highest average ratings.  If you chose this trainer, make sure you get the latest version as they have made improvements.  1up USA is located just north of us in Platteville, WI.  See video below of 1up USA trainer in use.

 

The Kurt Kinetic line of trainers are also very highly rated.

 

For the ultimate (at $850 a budget buster) roller setup.  Look at the e motion rollers from 1up USA.  They actually move within a frame, giving you a more lifelike ride feel.  There is a brief scene in the 2 min video below that shows the e motion rollers in use.

 

Permalink Reply by chixieonfixie on September 30, 2011 at 2:10pm

Respectfully disagree.

 

The ultimate roller setup are TruTrainers ( http://trutrainer.com/)  with their built in flywheel.  Their drums are the finest machined parts of any available rollers.  There is nothing like them in the world that comes so close to riding on the road.  May of the top cyclists in the area (in particular track cyclists) use these.

 

The rocking thing of the e-motion rollers is way overrated and kind of cheesy in my book.

John S. said:

A fluid based trainer is usually your best bet with the exception of 1up USA trainers.  Roadbike Review has a section for trainers.  As you can see it's sorted by rating.  I ignore anything with less than 10 people reviewing it.  The 1up USA trainer has over 100 reviews with one of the highest average ratings.  If you chose this trainer, make sure you get the latest version as they have made improvements.  1up USA is located just north of us in Platteville, WI.  See video below of 1up USA trainer in use.

 

The Kurt Kinetic line of trainers are also very highly rated.

 

For the ultimate (at $850 a budget buster) roller setup.  Look at the e motion rollers from 1up USA.  They actually move within a frame, giving you a more lifelike ride feel.  There is a brief scene in the 2 min video below that shows the e motion rollers in use.

 

Permalink Reply by chixieonfixie on September 30, 2011 at 2:15pm
PS - who on this thread is a competitive (as in racing) cyclist?
Permalink Reply by Michael A on September 30, 2011 at 3:41pm

I pay a lot of entry fees to race, I would not call myself competitive.. yet

 

Permalink Reply by John S. on September 30, 2011 at 6:40pm

Chixieonfixie, I stand corrected.  TruTrainers are one of the best. 

 

Permalink Reply by chixieonfixie on October 1, 2011 at 2:39am

ahh...not sure if you read up on the website and genuinely agree with me, John S, or you have just been married for a very long time :)

 

I do hope the former if you are ever in the market.  I researched and rode a lot of rollers before deciding on the TruTrainers...and it is a decision I will never regret. 


John S. said:

Chixieonfixie, I stand corrected.  TruTrainers are one of the best. 

 

Permalink Reply by Craig Williams on October 1, 2011 at 8:37am
I can't recommend rollers enough for the days when its too dangerous(slick) to be outside.  Once you've mastered them it's great fun.  For the days when it's just cold, Pearl Izumi lobster gloves, balaclava and neoprene face mask, booties or even better, water proof/wind proof socks.  I've been out in -15 degrees fahrenheit and had a great time!
Permalink Reply by S on October 1, 2011 at 10:29am
I've raced previously, I'm on the fence about cx this season but I'll definitely be racing road and cx next year.

chixieonfixie said:
PS - who on this thread is a competitive (as in racing) cyclist?
Permalink Reply by S on October 1, 2011 at 10:31am
The problem with rollers is that it's hard to get high wattage when you're using them even if you're using a flywheel attached to the trainer.  A lot of trainers let you get up to 2000+ W which is really hard to do on rollers.

chixieonfixie said:

Respectfully disagree.

 

The ultimate roller setup are TruTrainers ( http://trutrainer.com/)  with their built in flywheel.  Their drums are the finest machined parts of any available rollers.  There is nothing like them in the world that comes so close to riding on the road.  May of the top cyclists in the area (in particular track cyclists) use these.

 

Permalink Reply by John S. on October 1, 2011 at 3:45pm
I had read about the TruTrainers about a year ago. Bid on some on eBay. I think they went for $700+, too rich for me. I remember something about the guys that designed TruTrainers being aerospace engineers or something like that. Disagree about the cheezy comment about the e-motion. Seems like it might be more fun that just being stuck in one position on the rollers. Anyway, whatever floats your boat, they're both a good choice. However, the person that started this thread would probably be better off with a 1up USA or Kurt Kinetic trainer.

RSS

Groups

© 2008-2016   The Chainlink Community, L.L.C.   Powered by

Disclaimer  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service