"Sheldon Brown" locking technique--personal experiences

Hello,

I've read a lot of opinions about the Sheldon Brown lock strategy (http://sheldonbrown.com/lock-strategy.html). I understand that it can be defeated by cutting through the wheel, and that this is not as difficult to do as Sheldon claimed in that article.

However, I'm really interested to hear whether this actually happens much in Chicago (cutting the wheel), whether people still use this method, and whether they've had any problems with it.

I have an Abus Futura Mini that is too small to lock through both the frame and wheels (they have deep V rims which make them a little too wide (but maybe these are also a little harder to cut through?)). I really love the light weight and size of this lock and I would like to find a way to make it work rather than replacing it with something bigger and heavier. It is the perfect size for the Sheldon Brown method. Alternatively, of course, I could lock it through only the frame (but not the wheel). I'm wondering which is the better course of action.

Potentially-relevant details: I never leave the bike outside overnight. Usually when I'm locking it it's because I'm shopping or at a bar or restaurant, so it's there for a few hours maximum. The bike is a new (but low-end) single-speed hybrid/commuter/utility type bike. Wheels are bolt-on, not quick-release.

Thank you in advance!

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Thedutchtouch on May 20, 2013 at 12:02pm

The only thing that is hard to cut with a hack saw is the tire. The steel or aluminum wheel is cut, bent around the lock, and the tire is ripped off the rim. This leaves only the tire locked, while the mangled rim and attached frame are now free. I always lock the wheel AND part of the rear triangle.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Josh L. on May 20, 2013 at 12:40pm

hmm..I'll have to think about that but I'm sure you are right.

I probably park my bike 4-6x a day 350 days a year and have never ever seen a locked tire like this.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Will on May 21, 2013 at 3:08pm

Personally, I've used the Sheldon method a lot, and have never had a problem. I never, or very rarely, lock up overnight. I realize the Sheldon method is not perfect, but I do think the bike becomes relatively less attractive to a thief, once the rear wheel is destroyed.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Eli on May 21, 2013 at 3:17pm

I've appreciated all the advice and commentary in this thread.

I've continued to use the Sheldon method most of the time, since I rarely leave my bike locked outdoors for more than an hour or two, and since it is an inexpensive bike. But I think I would probably make a different decision if I had a more expensive bike and if I had to leave it locked unattended for a full eight-hour workday (or overnight).

On the other hand, at the rack where I saw that locked tire pictured above, I decided to lock through the frame instead! (The short shackle on my lock just doesn't fit both the wheel and the stays most of the time, depending on the diameter of the rack.)

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Allen Wrench on May 21, 2013 at 6:40pm

I think the whole issue is moot if you use a hardened chain instead. Allows you to lock around most streetlight poles, too. Sheldon may be right but why not just lock everything and be sure?

In the past with a U-Lock I used to get the rim, through the seat tube, then to the thing I was locking to, and it worked fine.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Josh L. on May 21, 2013 at 9:27pm

Based on this thread I've dropped teh Sheldon method as I have a recently expensive bike!

Eli Naeher said:

I've appreciated all the advice and commentary in this thread.

I've continued to use the Sheldon method most of the time, since I rarely leave my bike locked outdoors for more than an hour or two, and since it is an inexpensive bike. But I think I would probably make a different decision if I had a more expensive bike and if I had to leave it locked unattended for a full eight-hour workday (or overnight).

On the other hand, at the rack where I saw that locked tire pictured above, I decided to lock through the frame instead! (The short shackle on my lock just doesn't fit both the wheel and the stays most of the time, depending on the diameter of the rack.)