Dead Ride for Free on CTA with Fraud Rampant in Free Ride Program
Courtesy of Bob Matter
http://www.myfoxchicago.com/dpp/news/investigative/cta-seniors-ride...
Dead Ride for Free on CTA with Fraud Rampant in Free Ride Program
14% of all CTA rides are used by seniors for free
Updated: Wednesday, 24 Nov 2010, 8:59 AM CST
Published : Tuesday, 23 Nov 2010, 6:18 PM CST
By Dane Placko, FOX Chicago News
Chicago - For years we've joked about dead people voting in Chicago.
Now we know they take public transportation as well.
A joint investigation by FOX Chicago News and the Better Government
Association has uncovered widespread fraud and abuse in the "seniors
ride free" program -- including numerous cases where free passes
continue to be used on trains and buses long after the registered
cardholder died.
RTA spokesperson Diane Palmer says the agency recently completed a
review of more than 400,000 seniors ride free cards. And found 3,000
of the cardholders had died.
"We certainly know this is a travesty and something we've already
become aware of and are addressing," Palmer said.
But the RTA audit found about 160 cards belonging to those dead people
were still being used, presumably by friends and family. Those people
got anywhere from a few rides to as many as 1,400 free fares after
their loved one died.
And there's even evidence some of the cards are being sold.
"It absolutely is (taking advantage of a well-meaning program). And
again as I said, this is a time where the transit system is in dire
straits," Palmer said.
But that may be just the start of the fraud.
A potentially bigger problem that hasn't been measured is seniors
giving their free passes to riders who should pay.
Bob Herguth of the BGA and I decided to test the system one day last
week. We each used our fathers’ free ride cards.
And we were able to access the L at the Harrison Red Line station with
two CTA workers standing by.
Later we went through the unguarded entrance to the Brown Line's
Merchandise Mart stop, where a nearby attendant’s booth was empty.
Then we boarded the LaSalle Street bus for another free ride. And got
on a Howard Street Pace bus -- neither driver gave us a second look.
Okay, so we're two middle aged guys, which is why I then gave my dad's
pass to our FOX Chicago intern Marcella, who promptly used it to get
on the Red Line L at State Street.
When Marcella used the card, a beep sounded, which signals when a
seniors ride free pass is being used. But a CTA employee leaning
against a wall 15 feet away wasn't paying attention.
Minutes later Marcella used the card to get on the State Street bus.
Again, no reaction.
Was she surprised?
"Yeah, I don't really look like the guy. I'm 21 years old. I'm clearly
not a senior citizen getting on the bus," Marcella said.
"(The system) needs to have dramatic changes in terms of its oversight
and administration. Because it's so porous now it's crazy," the BGA’s
Herguth said.
“It’s theft,” he added.
Seniors ride free was the brainchild of former Gov. Rod Blagojevich,
who tied it to a regional tax hike for public transportation in 2008.
It was estimated the program would cost about $20 million.
But now that's soared to nearly $40 million, and republicans say based
on our findings of "riding while dead" and other fraud, it may be time
to send the whole program to the political graveyard.
"This was a political stunt by our former governor. Everybody knows it
was designed to get votes," said Tom Cross, Illinois House minority
leader.
"Unfortunately the current governor has said he does not want to
repeal that. I'm hopeful that given this type of information he will
reconsider,” Cross said.
###
Views: 213
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by T.C. O'Rourke on
-
This is a travesty and the people cheating the CTA should be arrested. Starting with Dane Placko, Bob Herguth and Marcella the intern.
Seriously 160 out of 400,000 cards being misused? I'd say nice work CTA.
And since when did Bob Matter start getting his news from Fox? His journey towards the dark side is complete!
-
Permalink Reply by Tank-Ridin' Ryan on
-
"Dead Ride for Free on CTA with Fraud Rampant in Free Ride Program"
Oh really FOX? Are we talking zombies riding the CTA or occupied coffins being transported on the CTA?
Idiots.
-
-
I stand by my "Idiots" remark - though I was really hoping for CTA of the Living Dead.
Kinda serves the CTA right though, what with having no financial limitations on getting a Senior Pass.
H3N3 said:Ryan, we're not talking about "Fox News Network" here-- I've found Fox local news to not be any more politically slanted than any of the other local news.
-
Permalink Reply by S on
-
Tank-Ridin' Ryan said:I stand by my "Idiots" remark - though I was really hoping for CTA of the Living Dead.
Kinda serves the CTA right though, what with having no financial limitations on getting a Senior Pass.
The free seniors thing wasn't something that the CTA/RTA wanted. A couple years ago when a compromise to fund the operating and capital requirements for the CTA/RTA and other transit agencies was finally hammered out and was on the verge of passing, Blago demanded the seniors ride for free thing otherwise he'd veto the bill. I remember that it was a bit of a shock to everyone working on the compromise and came out of nowhere. Anyhow, it got added in and for better or worse, it's now law I think.
-
-
...having their CTA cards used.
shapeshifter said:...i see dead people.
-
-
I still think it's a horribly misleading article title - I want zombies. Or what about Blago getting eaten by zombies?
H3N3 said:I appreciate your taking the time to compose this, although it definitely seems most folks would rather just blame the CTA for everything rather than have an understanding of how things actually work.
I still recall the news coverage the next day when Blago got himself booked at some senior event so he could be all over the news shaking hands and being congratulated. The reporters had a very hard time finding any seniors who had anything positive to say. Most interviewed said it added to negative perceptions of seniors as being burdens to society, and let it be known that they were willing and able to pay their fair share. Lots of unhappy faces, and that horrible "everybody loves me even if they don't realize it right now" grin on Blago's face . . .
S said:
Tank-Ridin' Ryan said:I stand by my "Idiots" remark - though I was really hoping for CTA of the Living Dead.
Kinda serves the CTA right though, what with having no financial limitations on getting a Senior Pass.
The free seniors thing wasn't something that the CTA/RTA wanted. A couple years ago when a compromise to fund the operating and capital requirements for the CTA/RTA and other transit agencies was finally hammered out and was on the verge of passing, Blago demanded the seniors ride for free thing otherwise he'd veto the bill. I remember that it was a bit of a shock to everyone working on the compromise and came out of nowhere. Anyhow, it got added in and for better or worse, it's now law I think.
-
Permalink Reply by Kevin C Dormant on
-
Surprised no one mentioned that the dead never give up their seats either.
-
-
Too busy being dead I guess.
Kevin Conway said:Surprised no one mentioned that the dead never give up their seats either.
-
Permalink Reply by Far'arned Retrogrumpalunkus #63 on
-
I wonder what kind of numbers could be crunched if they decided to just make the L trains free to all who wanted to ride them.
Just think of all the infrastructure and employees that could be eliminated.
Think of the number of people who would not be driving and the savings that would bring (and the roads that would be that much less crowded for bikes.
Sure it would mean a crapload more trains, and more power needed to run them as well as more conductors.
If they still charge for the busses then there would be more people on the trains and fewer on the belching stinky busses that block more traffic (and thus waste more fuel) than they save. Sure there are many places the trains don't go but its not a perfect solution.
There would also be more homeless in the stations (although there are quite a few in there now).
Positives and negatives I guess. I'd like to see the real numbers. I'd like to see the trains free. I'd like to see cattle cars on every train without any seats just for bikes. People could ride their bikes to the nearest train and take the train to the nearest stop and ride the rest of the way.
I think it'd be a much better system than it is today. The money that the city government wastes on stupid stuff that could be cut would be much better spent making the trains free. I just wonder how much it would really cost/year to just have it a free-for-all.
-
-
Chris C said:Any stats on the number of seniors who are now able to ride CTA that couldn't afford to do so before?
There's some stats here. It doesn't quite break out how the difference but apparently adding means testing to limit the free rides to those who really need it would add $38 million to the RTA budget. It's not that much compared to the $2.3 billion dollar budget. Still given that the RTA and CTA are chronically underfunded, every bit helps.
-
-
James Baum said:I wonder what kind of numbers could be crunched if they decided to just make the L trains free to all who wanted to ride them.
Just think of all the infrastructure and employees that could be eliminated.
The expenses are easy to figure out, it'd be about $520 million a year if everyone rode free. You'd be able to reduce costs a bit but probably not as much as you'd think. You still need people at the stations to provide security and deal with any problems. I don't expect the turnstiles and fareboxes add much in terms of costs, the major repair costs are with the trains and buses and repairs to structures.
Groups
-
Chicagoland Beer Explora…
203 members
-
Wednesday Night for Mort…
1 member
-
Great Lakes Ultra Cycling
270 members
-
Major Taylor Internation…
1 member
-
Critical Mass discussion
261 members
© 2008-2016 The Chainlink Community, L.L.C.
Powered by
