Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Steve Courtright on March 12, 2012 at 8:43am

I have lots of thoughts, John, only some of which I can share here with the short time I have to respond.  I started riding 20+ years ago when I was partially paralyzed after a disc went bad in my back.  So, I am very sensitive to this issue.

 

One important thing after keeping core strength up (and flexibility high) is to have a comfortable bike.  It must fit you, taking into consideration your lack of flexibility and must not transfer bumps up your spine to a great degree.  The current crop of carbon fiber bikes, while expensive, are nearly miraculous in this regard.  If I were you, I would replace that steel bike with a carbon-fiber cyclocross bike, with a carbon fiber fork and seat post, 35mm tires and 3x wheels for an additional bit of cushion.  Cross bikes are more flexible by design with a long wheelbase, and with a slightly more upright position.  That will make a huge difference. 

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by tmacz on March 12, 2012 at 1:06pm

I would love to give you an assesment of your core strength, and lumbar flexibility.  You should not be in pain, and the above advice was really good.  Could you have tweaked your back? Possibly doing something unrelated to the bike, recent lifting boxes, cleaning the basement, moving furniture...Also, getting an x-ray would help by giving you "up to date" skeletal health, as well as alignment and disc thinning.

 

I am the owner of Todays Chiropractic and Yoga Center if you choose to follow-up with me.  Good luck, keep riding, and watch out for geese!!

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by mike w. on March 12, 2012 at 2:04pm

i was diagnosed with stenosis a couple of years ago and eventually had a laminectomy at lumbar 4 & 5. Before the surgery i couldn't stand or walk without severe pain in my legs but could ride virtually pain free. My surgeon told me that i was about 6 months away from a wheelchair.

Later i learnt of a diagnostic indicator for my condition is the "bicycle test." Seems that the forward-leaning position bends the spine such that pressure on the spinal cord is relieved. My condition was such that standing up straight caused excruciating pains in my thighs and calves as well as hellacious cramps -especially at night.

i do have several bulging discs as well as a good case of ol' osteoarthritis... the lumbar region was just the worst hit area... it's hell to get old.

i ride a standard steel framed road bike with drop bars. My concession to age has been to raise the bars to just below seat height.

All this is by way of saying that a more upright position and staight bars may not be the best solution -you may need to be able to ride the drops and get some more curve in your back.

Just my $.02... YMMV. Good luck!

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by buddaa38 on March 12, 2012 at 6:04pm

Hey Howard,

Marlene just had spinal fusion done. Just a little pass 3months. Today was her 1st day back to work. I got her the best of the best of Doctor's from N.M.H. He was just voted top Doc's in this country. I agree totally with you. I think that she's going back to soon. at least they won't release her to water aerobics or her bike. He did say that if she wanted to use a stationary bike make it a recumbent . She thinks that she'll be back in the saddle by middle to end of this summer. I don't think so. Or she may have round 2 done. If anybody needs this Doctors name please contact me. He is the best. The back is VERY serious . Yes when she gets back in the saddle it would be more upright. Her Dr. wants her to keep her back straight up when sitting down. Like an L shape. I hope this may help.If not well it's their.

h' said:

Just because the more upright position caused more pain doesn't mean it was bad for you.

IN spinal stenosis, bending forward puts a stretch on the posterior longitudinal ligament, causing it to thin and giving the cord more room and thus temporarily relieving pain in some individuals.

Unfortunately I can't find an image that shows but the PLL and the spinal cord, but these two combined should give you an idea of the relationship.

That doesn't mean it would benefit you to spend long hours each day in a flexion posture-- think about what the consequence of that would be.

It's also likely that John's problem is fairly dissimilar to yours.

mike w. said:

i was diagnosed with stenosis a couple of years ago and eventually had a laminectomy at lumbar 4 & 5. Before the surgery i couldn't stand or walk without severe pain in my legs but could ride virtually pain free. My surgeon told me that i was about 6 months away from a wheelchair.

Later i learnt of a diagnostic indicator for my condition is the "bicycle test." Seems that the forward-leaning position bends the spine such that pressure on the spinal cord is relieved. My condition was such that standing up straight caused excruciating pains in my thighs and calves as well as hellacious cramps -especially at night.

i do have several bulging discs as well as a good case of ol' osteoarthritis... the lumbar region was just the worst hit area... it's hell to get old.

i ride a standard steel framed road bike with drop bars. My concession to age has been to raise the bars to just below seat height.

All this is by way of saying that a more upright position and straight bars may not be the best solution -you may need to be able to ride the drops and get some more curve in your back.

Just my $.02... YMMV. Good luck!

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Julie Aberman (Hochstadter) on March 16, 2012 at 8:55am

John- 

Dr. Tom (tmacz) is my chiropractor and amazing healer. I recommend contacting him if you haven't yet. I didn't believe in chiropractic care until I was so desperate, had constant pain, and finally took a friend's advice to see him.

tmacz said:

I would love to give you an assesment of your core strength, and lumbar flexibility.  You should not be in pain, and the above advice was really good.  Could you have tweaked your back? Possibly doing something unrelated to the bike, recent lifting boxes, cleaning the basement, moving furniture...Also, getting an x-ray would help by giving you "up to date" skeletal health, as well as alignment and disc thinning.

 

I am the owner of Todays Chiropractic and Yoga Center if you choose to follow-up with me.  Good luck, keep riding, and watch out for geese!!

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by John N. Phillips on March 16, 2012 at 9:22am

Julie - I have had 3 MRIs done on my back at considerable personal expense in the last 10 years, which basically told me I have three bad discs.  I do physical therapy for them 3 - 4X per week, and don't really live with much, if any pain.  But it does impede my bike riding enjoyment, and the amount of time I can spend on my bike.  The feedback here from this web site has been tremendous.  i will actually be setting up a chiropractor appointment in a week or two, but I think that I will also begin wearing a back brace when biking too (beginning this weekend).  I also might start looking into a carbon-fiber frame, and giving one a test drive soon.  Thanks to all for your comments, and to this site too.  Regards, John

Julie Hochstadter said:

John- 

Dr. Tom (tmacz) is my chiropractor and amazing healer. I recommend contacting him if you haven't yet. I didn't believe in chiropractic care until I was so desperate, had constant pain, and finally took a friend's advice to see him.

tmacz said:

I would love to give you an assesment of your core strength, and lumbar flexibility.  You should not be in pain, and the above advice was really good.  Could you have tweaked your back? Possibly doing something unrelated to the bike, recent lifting boxes, cleaning the basement, moving furniture...Also, getting an x-ray would help by giving you "up to date" skeletal health, as well as alignment and disc thinning.

 

I am the owner of Todays Chiropractic and Yoga Center if you choose to follow-up with me.  Good luck, keep riding, and watch out for geese!!

• ▶ Reply