The Chainlink

Lightfoot announced she’s nominating Gia Biagi as CDOT commissioner. Before her appointment, Biagi was a principal at Studio Gang in Chicago. She’s also been chief of staff at the Chicago Park District and has worked at the Department of Planning and Development, according to a news release.

Biagi will take over from acting Commissioner Thomas Carney, who had assumed the position temporarily after Rebekah Scheinfeld left in May. Carney will return to his previous role as first deputy, according to the release.

https://www.chicagotribune.com/politics/ct-lori-lightfoot-chicago-d...

No information on her stand on bicycles

Gia Biagi was nominated Dec. 10, 2019, to be the new commissioner of the Chicago Department of Transportation.

Views: 268

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Here's Streetsblog's writeup, with lots of endorsements of Biagi from transportation advocates:

https://chi.streetsblog.org/2019/12/10/advocates-laud-lightfoots-pi...

This is a good sign: Biagi worked a Gang Studios and "They were always Active Trans' Bike Commuter Challenge champions. The only company above 100 employees to reach 100% participation and they do it every year," according to the guy who used to run the commuter challenge.

Checking on past involvement in any other projects, and how those ultimately worked out?

https://thechainlink.org/forum/topics/northerly-island-path-collaps...

Not that any of this is easy... a lot of factors in play.

To be fair to Studio Gang, the plan they presented had elements included to deal with the wave issues, including barrier islands and break walls.  Those elements weren't implemented, and when you only implement half the plan and the results predictably play our poorly, not sure how much value there is to use that poor result to evaluate the planner.    

The Northerly Island Framework plan that Studio Gang worked on was completed in 2010. At that time Gia Biagi was still working as director of planning and development at the Park District. She didn't join Studio Gang until 2015.

The Framework Plan is basically a high-level concept plan and Studio Gang hired another subconsultant to design the shoreline protection (which as noted included barrier islands/reefs). Studio Gang wasn't involved beyond that. The Park District worked with the US Army Corp of Engineers to develop the detailed design and construction of the shoreline elements, which is the part that failed.

https://www.lrc.usace.army.mil/Missions/Civil-Works-Projects/Northe...

None of this really has anything to do with Gia Biagi's ability to lead CDOT, or her stance on bikes. 

As mentioned, not that any of it's easy, and, a lot of factors in play, some of which you guys touched on.  A concern at either organization (both at SG and Park District) may be the design culture and lack of emphasis on feasibility.  Those aren't necessarily reassuring at either organization in light of Northerly Island, that's all.  The risk in any of this is an environment where people sit in a charrette with things that look great on paper but don't pan out in the real world. That's how we get Milwaukee Ave or westbound Randolph from CDOT too. 

Other parties to point the finger at? You're right of course, the Army Corps, etc.  Still, hopefully Northerly Island (and Milwaukee Ave. elsewhere) offer lessons learned and things all work out. Meanwhile, whatever process lead to approving that whole barrier strategy and it's cost really needs a re-evaluation.  

 

RSS

© 2008-2016   The Chainlink Community, L.L.C.   Powered by

Disclaimer  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service